Our Menu

At Natalie’s Custom Cookies, every cookie is thoughtfully handmade to turn your celebration into something extra sweet. From birthdays and baby showers to weddings and corporate events, our custom sugar cookies are designed to match your theme, color palette, and vision. Each order is baked fresh, beautifully decorated, and crafted with attention to detail—because your moments deserve desserts that are just as special. Browse our menu to find the perfect cookies for your next event, and let us create something unforgettable, one cookie at a time.

Place an Order

Customized Sugar Cookies

All sugar cookies are a vanilla sugar cookie base, topped with royal icing

Packaged individually in basic cellophane bags

Pricing is based off of design

Regular Size: 1 dozen minimum (3-4inches): Starting at $55/Dozen

Minis: 1 Dozen Minimum (1-2inches): Starting at $30/Dozen

Additional Decor such as airbrush, metallic colors (gold,silver etc), piping florals are $3 extra per dozen

Chocolate Chunk Cookie (Mini's Also Available)

Soft-baked and loaded with rich chocolate chunks, these classic cookies are finished with a light pinch of flaky sea salt to perfectly balance every bite. Comforting, indulgent, and crowd-approved—these cookies are perfect for sharing (or keeping all to yourself).
Sold by the dozen. One dozen minimum.
$16 per dozen

Bite-sized, soft-baked mini cookies packed with rich chocolate chunks and finished with a delicate pinch of sea salt. Perfect for dessert tables, party platters, or when you want a little something sweet without the commitment.
Sold by the dozen. Two dozen minimum.
$8 per dozen

Birthday Cake White Oreo Cookies

A fun, celebratory cookie packed with birthday cake flavor, colorful sprinkles, and chunks of creamy white Oreo pieces. Soft, sweet, and nostalgic—perfect for birthdays, celebrations, or anytime you’re feeling festive.
Sold by the dozen.
$16 per dozen

Chocolate Chip Cookie Cups

Chocolate Cookie Cups
Rich chocolate cookie cups filled with smooth, creamy buttercream icing and topped with festive sprinkles. Perfect for parties, dessert tables, and special celebrations. Colors and sprinkles can be fully customized to match your theme.
24 cookie cups per order.
$40